Review Playbook

1. Why Reviews Build Trust

Hi there,

If you’ve landed on this playbook, you already know customer reviews matter. They’re the stories your customers tell about your brand. They’re the trust signals that convince someone to hit “Buy Now.” But let’s be honest—knowing reviews are important is one thing. Knowing how to use them to grow your eCommerce store is another.

That’s why we created this playbook.

You’ve probably seen guides about reviews before. So why another one? Because most guides barely scratch the surface. They tell you why reviews are great but don’t show you how to turn them into a retention superpower.

This playbook is different.

It’s built for every stage of your journey:

• Just starting out? Learn how to collect and display reviews that build trust.
• Growing your customer base? Discover how to turn reviews into a conversion engine.
• Scaling your brand? Use reviews to fuel loyalty and keep customers coming back.

Whether you’re setting up your first store or fine-tuning a business with thousands of customers, this playbook will meet you where you are—and help you go further.

What Makes This Playbook Special?

We didn’t just want to create another checklist. We wanted to give you a guide that’s:

• Comprehensive: Everything you need, from collecting reviews to using them to drive growth.
• Actionable: Tips, templates, and strategies you can implement today.
• Tailored to Your Goals: Whether you’re focused on trust, sales, or retention, this playbook adapts to your needs.

Why Are Reviews So Important?

If you’ve ever bought something online, you know the power of a great review. But they’re more than just a nice-to-have. They’re essential for your store’s success. Here’s why:

• They Build Trust: Reviews reassure first-time buyers that your brand delivers.
• They Increase Sales: Products with reviews convert better—it’s that simple.
• They Drive Retention: Engaging with reviews turns one-time buyers into repeat customers.
• They Boost SEO: Reviews bring fresh, authentic content that search engines love.

What’s Next?

This playbook is packed with practical insights to help you:

• Collect reviews effortlessly.
• Display them in the right places.
• Respond in ways that build even more trust.
• Turn reviews into a marketing goldmine.
• Use tools and templates to simplify your strategy.

By the end, you’ll have a proven system to make reviews work for you—whether you’re growing, scaling, or simply starting out.

Resources

1. Checklist: How to Ensure Authentic and Impactful Reviews
2. Worksheet: Worksheet: Map Your Review Strategy

💡 Love what you’re learning? Let’s keep going!

Subscribe to our newsletter The Art of Retention Marketing for:

• Helpful guides to master customer retention.
• Actionable insights to grow your sales.
• Proven tips to keep customers coming back.

Stay ahead of the game—join our community of eCommerce experts today!

Ready to get started? Let’s make reviews your next big win.

2. How Brands Use Reviews to Grow

Customer reviews are more than just feedback—they’re your most persuasive marketing tool. In this chapter, we’ll look at how real-world brands have used reviews to build trust, boost sales, and drive loyalty. Whether you’re just starting or scaling, these examples show how to harness the power of reviews at every stage of growth.

Amazon: The Original Review Powerhouse

It’s impossible to talk about reviews without mentioning Amazon. From the start, Amazon made reviews a central part of the shopping experience, building unparalleled trust. Their strategies include:

• Transparency: Displaying positive and negative reviews to help buyers make informed decisions.
• Volume: Encouraging reviews for every product, creating a sense of reliability.
• Verified Purchases: Highlighting reviews from actual buyers to boost credibility.

Takeaway: Even small brands can emulate Amazon by focusing on transparency and encouraging honest feedback.

Glossier: Turning Reviews Into a Marketing Goldmine

This D2C beauty brand built a cult following by transforming customer reviews into user-generated content (UGC). Their strategies include:

• Photo Reviews: Customers sharing selfies with products, creating authentic marketing visuals.
• Social Proof: Featuring reviews prominently on product pages and social media.
• Community Engagement: Encouraging reviewers to share their experiences as part of the brand story.

Takeaway: Visual reviews can double as trust-builders and social media content.

Warby Parker: Feedback for Improvement

Warby Parker, a D2C eyewear brand, uses reviews to not only boost sales but improve their offerings. Their strategies include:

• Product Refinement: Monitoring review trends to identify pain points and improve product quality.
• Building a Dialogue: Responding to reviews to show they value customer input.
• Review-Driven FAQs: Using recurring feedback to update FAQs and support content.

Takeaway: Reviews can be a goldmine for product improvement and customer support.

Allbirds: Building Loyalty With Reviews

Allbirds disrupted the footwear market by blending sustainability with comfort—and they leaned heavily on reviews to do it. Their strategies include:

• Storytelling Through Reviews: Highlighting reviews that emphasize comfort and eco-consciousness.
• Engaging Reviewers: Responding to customer reviews with gratitude and follow-ups.
• Cross-Promotion: Using reviews to cross-sell related products (e.g., socks with shoes).

Takeaway: Align reviews with your brand’s core values to attract loyal customers.

Brooklinen: Creating Luxury Through Feedback

Brooklinen made high-quality bedding accessible by positioning themselves as a luxury brand, and reviews played a critical role. Their strategies include:

• Highlighting Quality: Featuring reviews that focus on comfort and durability.
• Showcasing Longevity: Sharing reviews from repeat buyers to emphasize trust.
• Incorporating UGC: Using customer photos of cozy spaces in marketing campaigns.

Takeaway: Reviews can elevate your brand perception when strategically showcased.

Key Lessons From These Brands

No matter your niche, you can learn from these strategies:

• Encourage UGC: Ask customers to share photos or videos alongside reviews.
• Be Transparent: Show the good and the bad—authenticity builds trust.
• Engage with Reviews: Respond to feedback to create a two-way conversation.
• Use Reviews Everywhere: From product pages to social media, maximize their visibility.

Resources

• Case Study Collection: “Lessons from Top Brands on Using Reviews to Drive Retention.”
• Guide: “How to Create a Review Strategy Inspired by Industry Leaders.”

💡 Love what you’re learning? Let’s keep going!

Subscribe to The Art of Retention Marketing newsletter for:

• Helpful guides to master customer retention.
• Actionable insights to grow your sales.
• Proven tips to keep customers coming back.

Stay ahead of the game—join our community of eCommerce experts today!

3. How to Collect More Reviews

Getting customers to leave reviews can feel like a challenge, but it doesn’t have to be. With the right strategies, you can make review collection effortless—for both you and your customers. This chapter will show you how to ask for reviews, when to ask, and how to ensure a steady flow of authentic feedback.

Why Customers Don’t Leave Reviews

Before we dive into strategies, let’s address the barriers. Customers often don’t leave reviews because:

• They forget.
• The process feels time-consuming or complicated.
• They don’t see the value in providing feedback.

Your job is to remove these barriers by making it simple, quick, and rewarding.

When to Ask for Reviews

Timing is everything. Here’s when to request feedback:

• Post-Delivery: Send a request 5–7 days after the product is delivered. This gives customers time to use the product but keeps the experience fresh.
• After Positive Engagement: Ask for a review after a successful customer service interaction or a glowing comment on social media.
• Post-Purchase Milestones: For subscriptions or memberships, ask after a specific milestone, such as a renewal or reward redemption.

How to Ask for Reviews

1. Automated Emails:
   • Personalize the subject line (e.g., “We’d love your feedback on [Product Name]”).
   • Keep the message short and include a direct link to the review form.
   • Example template:
     Hi [Customer Name],
     Thank you for choosing [Brand Name]! We hope you’re loving your [Product Name].
     Could you take a minute to share your thoughts? Your feedback helps us improve and inspires other shoppers.
     [Leave a Review]
2. SMS Requests:
   • Use short, friendly texts with a direct link to the review page.
   • Example script:
     Hi [Customer Name], thanks for your recent purchase! We’d love to hear your thoughts. Share your review here: [link]
3. Incentives for Feedback:
   • Offer discounts, loyalty points, or exclusive perks for leaving a review.
   • Be transparent: Incentivize the act of leaving a review, not the content of the review.
4. QR Codes:
   • Include QR codes on packaging or receipts that link directly to the review page.
5. Social Media Prompts:
   • Ask followers to share their thoughts on your products with a branded hashtag.

How to Encourage Detailed and Diverse Reviews

Not all reviews are created equal. Here’s how to get feedback that truly resonates:

• Use Prompts: Guide customers with questions like:
  • “What did you love most about this product?”
  • “How did this product meet your expectations?”
• Encourage Multiple Formats:
  • Text reviews for detailed insights.
  • Photo reviews to showcase the product in real-life settings.
  • Video reviews for engaging, authentic feedback.

Automate the Process

Manually requesting reviews can be tedious. Automate the process with tools that:

• Send review requests based on customer actions (e.g., post-delivery).
• Provide pre-filled templates to simplify responses.
• Integrate with your CRM or eCommerce platform to track and manage reviews.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Being Pushy: Sending too many requests can frustrate customers.
2. Ignoring Mobile Users: Ensure your review forms are mobile-friendly.
3. Focusing Only on Positive Reviews: Authenticity matters—welcome all feedback.

Resources for This Chapter

• Email Templates: “Post-Purchase and Follow-Up Review Requests.”
• SMS Scripts: “Short and Effective Review Prompts for Mobile.”
• Checklist: “How to Set Up Automated Review Requests in 30 Minutes.”

💡 Love what you’re learning? Let’s keep going!

Subscribe to The Art of Retention Marketing newsletter for:

• Helpful guides to master customer retention.
• Actionable insights to grow your sales.
• Proven tips to keep customers coming back.

Stay ahead of the game—join our community of eCommerce experts today!

4. Where to Showcase Reviews

Collecting reviews is just the first step. Where you display them is what makes all the difference. Reviews need to be in the right place at the right time to influence your customers’ decisions. In this chapter, we’ll explore how to strategically showcase reviews across your store and marketing channels to maximize their impact.

Why Placement Matters

Think of reviews as digital word-of-mouth. They work best when they meet the customer during critical decision-making moments, whether it’s discovering your brand, choosing a product, or completing a purchase. Strategic placement can:

• Build trust with new visitors.
• Reduce hesitation during checkout.
• Reinforce loyalty with existing customers.

Where to Display Reviews

1. Product Pages: The Decision Point

Your product pages are the most important place to display reviews. Customers rely on them to make their final purchase decision.

• Include star ratings and summaries: Make the overall rating visible at the top.
• Feature top reviews: Highlight the most detailed, positive reviews.
• Allow filtering: Let customers sort reviews by rating, relevance, or recency.

2. Homepage: First Impressions Matter

Your homepage is where trust begins. Use it to create a strong first impression with reviews.

• Showcase your best reviews: Highlight glowing feedback as part of your value proposition.
• Use UGC: Include photos or videos from customers to add authenticity.

3. Checkout Page: Close the Sale

The checkout page is a make-or-break moment. Reviews can provide the final push.

• Display relevant reviews: Highlight feedback about the exact product(s) in the cart.
• Reinforce trust: Include testimonials about your brand’s reliability or customer service.

4. Email Campaigns: Retain and Convert

Use reviews in your email marketing to:

• Recover abandoned carts: Include product reviews to rebuild trust and urgency.
• Promote cross-sells and upsells: Use reviews to recommend complementary products.
• Re-engage inactive customers: Highlight new reviews of popular items.

5. Social Media: Expand Your Reach

Social platforms are ideal for amplifying your reviews.

• Turn reviews into posts: Share customer feedback as images, carousels, or reels.
• Leverage hashtags: Encourage customers to tag your brand and use a branded hashtag.
• Run ads: Use review snippets in paid campaigns to boost conversion rates.

6. Dedicated Review Pages: All in One Place

Create a centralized hub for all your reviews.

• Showcase all product reviews: Allow customers to browse feedback across your catalog.
• Build trust for new products: Include general brand reviews to compensate for items with fewer reviews.
• Boost SEO: A dedicated page filled with user-generated content can drive organic traffic.

Pro Tips for Showcasing Reviews

• Refresh regularly: Keep your reviews page up-to-date with recent feedback.
• Highlight diversity: Showcase reviews from customers with different needs and preferences.
• Match your branding: Ensure the design of your review displays aligns with your store’s look and feel.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Hiding negative reviews: Displaying only glowing feedback can come across as inauthentic.
• Cluttering pages: Too many reviews or poor formatting can overwhelm customers.
• Ignoring placement opportunities: Don’t limit reviews to just product pages—make them visible across your customer journey.

Resources for This Chapter

• Checklist: “Best Practices for Displaying Reviews Across Channels.”
• Swipe File: “Review Display Ideas from Real eCommerce Stores.”
• Template: “Designing a Dedicated Reviews Page That Converts.”

💡 Love what you’re learning? Let’s keep going!

Subscribe to The Art of Retention Marketing newsletter for:

• Helpful guides to master customer retention.
• Actionable insights to grow your sales.
• Proven tips to keep customers coming back.

Stay ahead of the game—join our community of eCommerce experts today!