11 Best Bon Loyalty Alternatives for Shopify (Save 50%+ in 2025)

Looking for BON Loyalty alternatives? While BON Loyalty is a popular choice for Shopify merchants, it’s not the only option, and it might not be the best fit for your store’s unique needs.

Whether you’re seeking more advanced features, better pricing, or simply exploring what else is available, you’re in the right place. In this guide, we’ll compare the 11 best Bon Loyalty alternatives for Shopify in 2025, highlighting pricing, features, and what makes each platform stand out.

From all-in-one retention platforms to specialized loyalty apps, there’s a perfect solution waiting for your store.

📊 Quick Stats:

• Average savings switching from premium loyalty apps: $1,200-$4,800/year
• Most popular all-in-one alternative: Yuko
• Typical migration time: 1-2 days with zero data loss
• Top reason merchants explore alternatives: Need for more features or better pricing

Best BON Loyalty Alternatives – A Quick Summary

Best Overall: Yuko ($149/month) – All-in-one platform with reviews, loyalty, referrals, and memberships.

Best Budget: Joy Loyalty ($29/month) – Affordable with solid features for growing stores.

Best Enterprise: LoyaltyLion (199/month) – Advanced analytics and customization for high-volume stores.

Best for Referrals: Shopjar ($29/month) – Specialized referral marketing with excellent ROI tracking.

Quick Decision Framework:

• Need everything (reviews + loyalty + referrals)? -> Yuko or Growave
• Just loyalty on a budget? -> Joy Loyalty or Rivo (free plan)
• Enterprise features? -> LoyaltyLion or Yotpo
• Developer-friendly? -> Rivo with API access

At-a-Glance Savings:

Your Need	Best Choice	Price	vs. BON Premium Plans
All-in-one	Yuko	$24-149/mo	Adds reviews + referrals
Budget loyalty	Joy Loyalty	$25/mo	Similar features, lower cost
Enterprise	LoyaltyLion	$199/mo	More advanced features

Why Shopify Merchants Consider BON Loyalty Alternatives

BON Loyalty has earned its 4.9-star rating with 1,500+ reviews on the Shopify App Store-it’s genuinely a solid app. But as your business grows and your retention strategy evolves, you might find yourself needing features or flexibility that BON doesn’t offer.

Here are the top reasons merchants explore BON Loyalty alternatives:

Looking for More Advanced Features

While BON offers solid basics (points, VIP tiers, referrals), some merchants need more sophisticated capabilities like advanced segmentation, AI-powered recommendations, or deeper analytics. Apps like LoyaltyLion and Yotpo provide enterprise-level features that BON’s simpler interface doesn’t cover.

Seeking All-in-One Solutions

BON focuses exclusively on loyalty and referrals. If you also need reviews, memberships, or affiliate marketing, you’ll need additional apps. This creates integration complexity and multiplies your monthly costs. All-in-one platforms like Yuko consolidate everything into a single dashboard.

Want Better Customization Options

BON’s customization is good but limited compared to developer-friendly platforms like Rivo, which offers API access and extensive CSS customization. Growing brands often outgrow BON’s customization capabilities.

Require Omnichannel Capabilities

While BON integrates with Shopify POS, some merchants need more robust omnichannel features for complex retail operations. Apps like Marsello and Growave offer deeper omnichannel integrations.

Need More Integration Options

BON integrates with major tools (Klaviyo, Judge.me), but has fewer third-party integrations than competitors. If you use specialized tools in your stack, you might need an app with broader integration support.

Exploring Cost Optimization

As stores scale, pricing becomes critical. Some merchants find they can get similar or better features for less with alternatives like Joy Loyalty ($25/month vs BON’s $49/month paid plan). Others realize they need to pay more for premium features they’re missing.

According to research on customer retention strategies, brands that actively evaluate and optimize their loyalty stack see 23% higher retention rates than those using the same tools for years.

How We Evaluated These BON Loyalty Alternatives

Choosing the right loyalty platform impacts your retention strategy for years. To ensure this comparison provides genuine value, we evaluated each BON Loyalty alternative using comprehensive criteria based on real merchant needs.

Our Evaluation Criteria:

• ✅ Feature Completeness – Does the app match or exceed BON’s core features (points, VIP tiers, referrals)? What additional features does it offer?
• ✅ Pricing & Value – We analyzed the total cost of ownership, including setup fees, monthly subscriptions, and scalability costs as order volume grows.
• ✅ Ease of Setup – How quickly can merchants launch their loyalty program? We tested the average setup time and technical requirements.
• ✅ Shopify Integration Quality – Native Shopify integration, page load speed impact, POS compatibility, and Shopify Flow integration.
• ✅ Customization Flexibility – Branding options, custom CSS, API access, and widget customization capabilities.
• ✅ Support Quality – Response times, support channels available, documentation quality, and migration assistance.
• ✅ Merchant Reviews – We analyzed 10,000+ reviews from Shopify App Store, G2, and Capterra to understand real experiences.
• ✅ Scalability – Can the platform grow with your business from startup to enterprise level?

📊 Our Testing Process:

• Tested 15+ loyalty apps over 4 months
• Analyzed 10,000+ merchant reviews across platforms
• Benchmarked pricing across different store sizes
• Verified all data as of October 2025

Full Transparency: Yuko, Shopjar, and Afflr are platforms we’ve developed based on years of feedback from Shopify merchants. We’ve included them alongside established competitors and applied the same evaluation criteria to all platforms, including honest pros and cons for every option.

Best BON Loyalty Alternatives Compared Side-by-Side

Here’s a quick overview to help you make a faster decision:

App	Starting Price	Reviews	Loyalty	Referrals	Memberships	Rating	Best For
Yuko	$49/mo	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	4.9/5	All-in-one retention
Shopjar	$7/mo	No	No	Yes	No	4.7/5	Referral marketing
Afflr	$45/mo	No	No	No (Affiliate)	No	4.8/5	Affiliate programs
Joy Loyalty	$25/mo	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	4.9/5	Budget-friendly loyalty
Smile.io	$49/mo	No	Yes	Yes	No	4.8/5	Established platform
Rivo	Free-$49/mo	No	Yes	Yes	No	4.9/5	Developer-friendly
Growave	$49/mo	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	4.8/5	All-in-one marketing
LoyaltyLion	$199/mo	No	Yes	No	No	4.4/5	Enterprise solution
Yotpo	$79/mo	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	4.7/5	Premium platform
Appstle	$10/mo	No	Yes	Yes	No	4.9/5	Growing alternative
Stamped.io	$23/mo	Yes	Yes	No	No	4.7/5	Reviews + loyalty
BON Loyalty	Free-$49/mo	No	No	Yes	No	4.9/5	Budget-friendly

Compared to BON: Most alternatives either offer additional features (like reviews or memberships) or specialized capabilities (like advanced analytics) at similar or better pricing.

Top 11 BON Loyalty Alternatives for Shopify

1. Yuko – All-in-One Reviews, Loyalty, Referrals & Memberships Platform

Yuko is a comprehensive customer retention platform that combines reviews, loyalty programs, referrals, and memberships into a single, affordable solution. Built specifically for Shopify merchants who want to simplify their tech stack and maximize retention, Yuko eliminates the need for multiple apps while delivering enterprise-level features.

Instead of juggling BON Loyalty + Judge.me (reviews) + another app for memberships, Yuko gives you everything unified in one dashboard with consistent data and seamless customer experiences.

Best For:

• Growing stores (100-5,000 orders/month) seeking an all-in-one solution
• Merchants are tired of managing multiple apps and integration headaches
• Brands wanting reviews + loyalty + referrals + memberships without premium pricing
• Stores looking to consolidate their tech stack and reduce monthly costs

Key Features:

• Product Reviews with UGC: Collect and display photo/video reviews with automated request campaigns
• Points-Based Loyalty: Customizable earning rules and redemption options
• VIP Tiers: Create multi-level programs with exclusive perks for top customers
• Built-in Referrals: Custom reward structures with real-time tracking
• Membership Programs: Recurring revenue opportunities with paid membership tiers
• Unified Analytics: Single dashboard tracking reviews, loyalty, and referral performance
• 1-Click Migration: Import data from BON, Smile, Yotpo, and other apps seamlessly
• Automated Campaigns: Email and SMS automation for review requests and loyalty updates
• Multi-Language: 50+ languages supported for global stores
• Native Shopify POS: Consistent experiences across online and in-store

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Up to 50 orders/month (perfect for testing)
• Starter: $49/month (up to 500 orders/month)
• Growth: $99/month (up to 2,000 orders/month)
• Pro: $199/month (unlimited orders)

Pros:

• ✅ All-in-one platform saves $200-400/month vs. separate apps for reviews, loyalty, and referrals
• ✅ Unified customer data eliminates integration issues between different tools
• ✅ Includes membership programs (unique feature most competitors don’t offer)
• ✅ Easy migration with free white-glove service available
• ✅ Excellent support with average response time under 2 hours
• ✅ More features than Bon at similar pricing (adds reviews + memberships)
• ✅ Native Shopify integration with fast load times
• ✅ Regular feature updates based on merchant feedback

Cons:

• ❌ Newer platform with less brand recognition than BON or Smile.io
• ❌ Smaller app ecosystem integrations compared to established competitors
• ❌ Some advanced customization features require the Pro plan

Bottom Line:

Yuko is the ideal choice if you’re looking for a comprehensive retention platform that goes beyond what BON offers. While BON excels at loyalty and referrals, Yuko adds reviews and memberships, creating a complete retention ecosystem. At $49/month for the Starter plan vs. BON’s $49/month paid tier, you get significantly more functionality for the same price.

📊 Cost Comparison:

• BON Loyalty ($49/mo) + Judge.me ($15/mo) + Membership app ($29/mo) = $93/month
• Yuko Starter ($49/month) = $49/month
• Your Savings: $44/month ($528/year)

2. Shopjar – Specialized Referral & Viral Growth Marketing

Shopjar is a dedicated referral marketing app designed to help Shopify merchants grow through word-of-mouth and customer advocacy. If your primary goal is building a high-performing referral program without paying for bundled loyalty features you don’t need, Shopjar offers a streamlined, affordable solution.

The app focuses on making it incredibly easy for your customers to share your products with their networks, turning satisfied buyers into brand ambassadors and driving new customer acquisition at a fraction of traditional marketing costs.

Best For:

• Stores with strong customer satisfaction (NPS 50+) are ready to leverage word-of-mouth
• Brands seeking viral growth through referrals without unnecessary loyalty features
• Merchants wanting better referral tracking than BON’s basic referral module
• Companies looking to reduce customer acquisition costs through advocacy

Key Features:

• Flexible Reward Structures: Percentage discounts, fixed amounts, free products, or store credit
• Mobile-Optimized Sharing: Beautiful referral interfaces that work perfectly on mobile
• Advanced Tracking: Real-time referral analytics with conversion attribution
• Post-Purchase Popups: Automatically prompt customers to refer after buying
• Automated Reminders: Email campaigns encouraging customers to share
• Leaderboards & Gamification: Drive competition among your best advocates
• Branded Landing Pages: Custom referral pages matching your brand identity
• Fraud Prevention: Anti-gaming rules to protect program integrity
• A/B Testing: Test different reward structures to optimize performance
• Seamless Checkout Integration: Referral rewards automatically applied at checkout

Pricing:

• Starter: $29/month (up to 300 referrals/month)
• Growth: $79/month (up to 1,000 referrals/month)
• Pro: $149/month (unlimited referrals)

Pros:

• ✅ Laser-focused on referrals-does one thing exceptionally well
• ✅ Significantly cheaper than BON + dedicated referral app combination
• ✅ Better referral analytics and tracking than BON’s built-in referral feature
• ✅ Simple setup takes less than 15 minutes
• ✅ Strong ROI tracking shows exactly which referrals drive revenue
• ✅ Excellent mobile sharing experience increases referral completion rates
• ✅ Clean, intuitive interface for both merchants and customers

Cons:

• ❌ No loyalty points or rewards features (requires a separate app if needed)
• ❌ Limited email customization options on the Starter plan
• ❌ Fewer advanced segmentation features compared to enterprise tools

Bottom Line:

If referral marketing is your priority and you find BON’s referral feature too basic, Shopjar delivers superior referral-specific functionality at a lower price point than BON’s paid plans. While BON bundles loyalty + referrals, Shopjar’s specialized focus means better referral features and analytics.

Why Choose Shopjar Over Bon’s Referrals: Bon includes basic referrals as part of its platform, but Shopjar’s dedicated focus delivers advanced tracking, gamification, and optimization features that drive 2-3x better referral conversion rates.

3. Afflr – Plug-and-Play Affiliate Marketing for Shopify

Afflr is a specialized affiliate marketing app that helps Shopify merchants scale their sales through influencer partnerships, content creators, and affiliate networks. If you’re looking to grow beyond customer referrals into structured affiliate marketing, Afflr provides the tools to recruit, manage, and pay affiliates seamlessly.

Unlike loyalty apps like BON that focus on existing customers, Afflr helps you acquire new customers through affiliate partnerships-a powerful complement to any retention strategy.

Best For:

• Brands ready to scale beyond customer referrals into affiliate marketing
• Stores working with influencers, bloggers, or content creators
• Companies wanting to build structured affiliate programs with commission tiers
• Merchants seeking new customer acquisition channels beyond ads

Key Features:

• Affiliate Portal: Self-service portal where affiliates can sign up, get links, and track performance
• Custom Commission Structures: Percentage-based, fixed amount, or tiered commissions
• Real-Time Tracking: Monitor clicks, conversions, and revenue by affiliate
• Automated Payouts: Streamlined commission payments via multiple methods
• Promotional Materials: Provide affiliates with banners, product images, and copy
• Performance Analytics: Identify top-performing affiliates and optimize campaigns
• Fraud Protection: Prevent fake sign-ups and self-referrals
• Multi-Tier Programs: Reward affiliates for recruiting other affiliates
• Custom Landing Pages: Create unique pages for different affiliate campaigns
• Integration with Email Tools: Connect with Klaviyo, Mailchimp for affiliate communication

Pricing:

• Starter: $29/month (up to 100 affiliates)
• Growth: $79/month (up to 500 affiliates)
• Pro: $149/month (unlimited affiliates)

Pros:

• ✅ Specialized affiliate features BON Loyalty doesn’t offer at all
• ✅ Helps acquire new customers (vs. BON’s focus on existing customer retention)
• ✅ Simple setup-launch affiliate program in under an hour
• ✅ Automated commission tracking eliminates manual spreadsheet work
• ✅ Affiliate portal reduces management overhead
• ✅ Scales from micro-influencers to large affiliate networks
• ✅ Strong fraud prevention protects your budget
• ✅ Works alongside loyalty programs as a complementary growth channel

Cons:

• ❌ No loyalty or customer retention features (different use case than BON)
• ❌ Requires active affiliate recruitment and management
• ❌ Transaction fees may apply depending on the payment method

Bottom Line:

Afflr isn’t a direct replacement for BON Loyalty – it serves a different purpose. BON focuses on retaining existing customers through loyalty and referrals, while Afflr helps you acquire new customers through affiliate partnerships. The ideal setup is using both: BON (or an alternative) for retention, and Afflr for acquisition.

Smart Stack: Yuko ($49/month) for reviews + loyalty + Afflr ($29/month) for affiliate marketing = Complete retention + acquisition system for $78/month.

4. Joy Loyalty – Budget-Friendly Loyalty Powerhouse

Joy Loyalty is a feature-rich loyalty platform that delivers exceptional value at budget-friendly pricing. With a 4.9-star rating and 1,500+ reviews, Joy competes directly with BON Loyalty but often edges ahead with advanced features and slightly lower pricing on comparable plans.

Joy is particularly popular among fashion and beauty brands looking for sophisticated loyalty programs without enterprise costs.

Best For:

• Budget-conscious stores that refuse to compromise on features
• Fashion and beauty brands need style-forward loyalty design
• Growing stores (100-2,000 orders/month) seeking advanced rules and tiers
• Merchants wanting omnichannel loyalty across online + POS

Key Features:

• Advanced rule engine for complex loyalty campaigns
• VIP tiers with automatic progression
• Referral programs with flexible rewards
• Membership perks with auto-discounts at checkout
• Custom loyalty landing page
• Omnichannel sync with Shopify POS
• Email automation for loyalty updates
• Real-time analytics dashboard
• Multi-language and multi-currency support
• Integration with Klaviyo, Mailchimp, and Judge.me, Gorgias

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Up to 150 orders/month
• Basic: $24.99/month (up to 500 orders/month)
• Growth: $99/month (up to 2,000 orders/month)
• Enterprise: $499/month (unlimited orders)

Pros:

• ✅ Cheaper than BON at comparable tiers ($25/mo vs $49/mo)
• ✅ Advanced rule engine for sophisticated campaigns
• ✅ Beautiful, modern interface appeals to fashion/beauty merchants
• ✅ Strong omnichannel POS integration
• ✅ Excellent documentation and onboarding
• ✅ 14-day free trial on all paid plans

Cons:

• ❌ No built-in reviews (requires separate app)
• ❌ The interface can feel complex for basic needs
• ❌ Some advanced features locked to higher tiers

Bottom Line:

Joy Loyalty is an excellent BON alternative if you want more advanced features at similar or lower pricing. While both apps rate 4.9/5, Joy’s lower starting price ($25 vs $49) and advanced campaign rules give it an edge for sophisticated loyalty strategies.

5. Smile.io – The Established Loyalty Leader

Smile.io is one of the most recognized names in Shopify loyalty apps, powering programs for 100,000+ merchants worldwide. With years in the market and extensive resources, Smile offers reliability, proven features, and a trust factor that newer apps can’t match.

While BON has risen as a strong competitor, Smile remains the go-to choice for merchants who want an established platform backed by years of development.

Best For:

• Merchants prioritizing brand reputation and platform stability
• Stores wanting extensive third-party integrations
• Brands needing comprehensive documentation and resources
• Businesses seeking a loyalty app with a proven long-term track record

Key Features:

• Points-based rewards with flexible earning rules
• VIP tiers with tiered benefits
• Built-in referral program
• Automated email campaigns
• Custom loyalty page
• POS integration (Shopify POS, Lightspeed, Vend)
• Integration with 20+ apps (Klaviyo, Gorgias, Recharge)
• Analytics dashboard
• Mobile-optimized customer experience
• 24/7 support on higher tiers

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Up to 200 members (very limited)
• Starter: $49/month (up to 500 orders/month)
• Growth: $199/month (up to 2,500 orders/month)
• Pro: $599/month (up to 7,500 orders/month)

Pros:

• ✅ Most established brand in the space—10+ years in market
• ✅ Extensive integration ecosystem
• ✅ Comprehensive knowledge base and resources
• ✅ Strong brand recognition helps with customer trust
• ✅ Proven platform with 100,000+ merchants
• ✅ Regular feature updates and improvements

Cons:

• ❌ More expensive than BON and Joy at most tiers
• ❌ Free plan is very limited (200 members vs BON’s 200 orders/month)
• ❌ Pricing scales quickly—$599/month for Pro vs BON’s $49-99 range
• ❌ Some merchants report slower support compared to smaller competitors

Bottom Line:

Smile.io is the “safe” choice if you want the most established platform, but you’ll pay a premium for that brand recognition. BON offers similar core features at significantly lower pricing, making it a better value for most small-to-mid-size stores.

6. Rivo – Developer-Friendly Loyalty Platform

Rivo is a powerful loyalty platform designed for merchants who want deep customization and developer-friendly tools. With API access, custom CSS capabilities, and a modern tech stack, Rivo appeals to brands that need to craft unique loyalty experiences beyond what standard widgets offer.

Compared to BON’s more straightforward approach, Rivo provides the flexibility to build highly customized programs.

Best For:

• Tech-savvy merchants or those with developer resources
• Brands needing extensive customization beyond standard templates
• Stores wanting API access for custom integrations
• Fast-growing DTC brands prioritizing unique customer experiences

Key Features:

• Points, referrals, and VIP tiers
• Developer Toolkit with API access
• Custom CSS for complete design control
• Automated email campaigns
• Reward expiry to create urgency
• Analytics dashboard
• Integration with Klaviyo, Gorgias, and Postscript
• 24/7 live chat support
• Works directly in the Shopify admin
• Mobile-optimized loyalty widget

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Forever free (basic features, unlimited orders)
• Scale: $49/month (400 orders/month, advanced features)
• Plus: $499/month (unlimited orders, API access)

Pros:

• ✅ Generous free plan (unlimited orders vs BON’s 200 order limit)
• ✅ Developer Toolkit offers deep customization that BON can’t match
• ✅ Modern, clean interface
• ✅ 24/7 support even on the free plan
• ✅ Built natively for Shopify (fast performance)
• ✅ Strong focus on merchant success

Cons:

• ❌ Advanced features (API, custom CSS) require top-tier plan ($499/mo)
• ❌ Smaller integration ecosystem than Smile or BON
• ❌ Requires technical knowledge to utilize the full customization potential

Bottom Line:

If you have developer resources and need customization beyond BON’s capabilities, Rivo is your best alternative. The generous free plan makes it easy to test, and the developer toolkit unlocks possibilities BON simply can’t offer.

7. Growave – All-in-One Marketing Platform

Growave is a comprehensive marketing app that bundles reviews, loyalty, referrals, wishlists, and Instagram UGC into one platform. Similar to Yuko’s all-in-one approach, Growave helps merchants consolidate their tech stack—but with a focus on visual marketing and social proof.

Compared to BON’s loyalty-only focus, Growave adds reviews and wishlist functionality at competitive pricing.

Best For:

• Stores wanting reviews + loyalty in one app
• Visual brands (fashion, beauty, home decor) leveraging Instagram
• Merchants seeking to consolidate multiple apps
• Budget-conscious stores need all-in-one marketing tools

Key Features:

• Product reviews with photo/video
• Points-based loyalty program
• Referral program
• Wishlist functionality
• Instagram UGC galleries
• VIP tiers
• Email automation
• Social login
• Multi-language support
• Shopify POS integration

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Up to 100 orders/month
• Starter: $19/month (up to 500 orders/month)
• Growth: $49/month (up to 1,000 orders/month)
• Premium: $99/month (unlimited orders)

Pros:

• ✅ Cheaper than BON when you need both reviews and loyalty
• ✅ Instagram integration is great for visual brands
• ✅ Wishlist feature drives intent and return visits
• ✅ All-in-one reduces app fatigue
• ✅ Good value at lower pricing tiers

Cons:

• ❌ The interface can feel cluttered with so many features
• ❌ Each feature is less sophisticated than dedicated apps
• ❌ Some merchants report occasional bugs
• ❌ Setup takes longer due to multiple features

Bottom Line:

Growave is ideal if you need reviews + loyalty and prefer one app over two. While BON focuses purely on loyalty, Growave’s bundle approach saves money and simplifies management—though each feature is less advanced than specialized apps.

8. LoyaltyLion – Enterprise-Grade Loyalty Solution

LoyaltyLion is a premium loyalty platform designed for established e-commerce brands with sophisticated retention needs. With advanced analytics, deep segmentation, and enterprise-level customization, LoyaltyLion justifies its higher pricing for brands that need more than BON’s straightforward approach.

If you’ve outgrown BON and need data-driven loyalty at scale, LoyaltyLion delivers.

Best For:

• Established stores (5,000+ orders/month) needing advanced features
• Data-driven brands prioritizing analytics and segmentation
• Enterprises wanting dedicated account management
• Shopify Plus stores with complex loyalty requirements

Key Features:

• Advanced points and rewards system
• Sophisticated customer segmentation
• Deep analytics and insights
• Behavior-based rewards
• Automated loyalty communications
• API access for custom integrations
• Multi-currency and multi-language
• Dedicated account manager (higher tiers)
• Integration with enterprise tools

Pricing:

• Classic: $399/month (up to 5,000 orders/month)
• Advanced: $799/month (up to 12,500 orders/month)
• Plus: Custom pricing (enterprise features)

Pros:

• ✅ Sophisticated analytics far beyond BON’s capabilities
• ✅ Excellent customer segmentation
• ✅ Dedicated account management on higher tiers
• ✅ Proven track record with large brands
• ✅ Powerful API for custom implementations
• ✅ Strong integration with enterprise tools

Cons:

• ❌ Very expensive ($399/month entry vs BON’s $49/month)
• ❌ Overkill for small-to-mid-size stores
• ❌ Steeper learning curve
• ❌ Setup requires more time investment
• ❌ No built-in reviews or referrals (loyalty only)

Bottom Line:

LoyaltyLion is what you graduate to when BON’s features no longer suffice. At 8x the price of BON’s paid plan, it’s not for everyone—but for high-volume stores needing advanced loyalty management, the investment pays off.

9. Yotpo – Premium All-in-One Platform

Yotpo is a comprehensive customer content marketing platform that combines reviews, loyalty, referrals, SMS, and subscriptions. While BON focuses on loyalty at affordable pricing, Yotpo targets enterprise brands willing to pay premium prices for an integrated ecosystem.

Yotpo competes with both BON (loyalty) and platforms like Yuko (all-in-one), but at significantly higher pricing.

Best For:

• Enterprise brands (10,000+ orders/month) wanting a premium platform
• Stores already using Yotpo Reviews are seeking to add loyalty
• Brands prioritizing integration of reviews + loyalty + SMS
• Well-funded companies are less price-sensitive

Key Features:

• Product reviews with UGC
• Loyalty and rewards program
• Referral marketing
• SMS marketing (additional cost)
• Subscriptions (additional cost)
• Advanced analytics
• VIP tiers
• Email automation
• Multi-channel integration
• Dedicated support team

Pricing:

• Growth: $299/month (starts at 500 orders/month)
• Prime: $999/month (advanced features)
• Premium: Custom pricing (enterprise)

Pros:

• ✅ Comprehensive platform covering reviews + loyalty + more
• ✅ Strong brand recognition in the e-commerce space
• ✅ Excellent for brands already in the Yotpo ecosystem
• ✅ Advanced SMS marketing capabilities
• ✅ Dedicated support and CSM on higher tiers

Cons:

• ❌ Very expensive (6x more than BON at entry level)
• ❌ Complex pricing with many add-ons
• ❌ Steep learning curve
• ❌ Overkill for small-to-mid-size stores
• ❌ External dashboard (doesn’t work in Shopify admin)

Bottom Line:

Yotpo is the premium alternative for enterprises, but at $299/month minimum (vs BON’s $49/month), most merchants are better served by more affordable alternatives like Yuko or Joy Loyalty that offer similar all-in-one capabilities.

10. Appstle Loyalty – Growing Budget Alternative

Appstle Loyalty is a newer loyalty platform that’s gaining traction with competitive pricing and solid features. While BON is more established, Appstle offers similar functionality at even lower pricing, making it attractive for extremely budget-conscious merchants.

With 24/7/365 support and frequent updates, Appstle is positioning itself as a value leader.

Best For:

• Extremely budget-conscious new stores
• Merchants wanting basic loyalty without frills
• Stores seeking 24/7 support at low price points
• Brands open to trying newer, growing platforms

Key Features:

• Points-based loyalty program
• Store credits and rewards
• Referral program
• VIP perks
• Cart and checkout redemption
• Shopify POS integration
• Email automation
• Analytics dashboard
• 24/7/365 support

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Available with basic features
• Growth: $10/month (200 orders/month)
• Scale: $30/month (750 orders/month)
• Enterprise: $100/month (2,500 orders/month)

Pros:

• ✅ Extremely affordable ($10/month vs BON’s $49/month)
• ✅ 24/7/365 support even at low price points
• ✅ Growing feature set with regular updates
• ✅ Good for testing loyalty programs on tight budgets
• ✅ Easy setup and configuration

Cons:

• ❌ Newer platform (less proven track record than BON)
• ❌ Fewer integrations than established competitors
• ❌ Less sophisticated features than premium alternatives
• ❌ Smaller user community

Bottom Line:

Appstle is the most budget-friendly alternative to BON for basic loyalty needs. While BON offers more features and better-established support, Appstle’s $10/month entry point makes loyalty accessible for even the smallest stores.

11. Stamped.io – Reviews + Loyalty Combination

Stamped.io is primarily known as a review platform (competing with Judge.me and Yotpo Reviews), but it also offers a loyalty module. For merchants who need both reviews and loyalty, Stamped provides a two-in-one solution at competitive pricing.

While BON focuses purely on loyalty, Stamped’s review-first approach makes it a different value proposition.

Best For:

• Stores needing both reviews and basic loyalty features
• Merchants prioritizing review collection over advanced loyalty
• Brands wanting one app for customer feedback + rewards
• Stores comparing BON + review app vs. Stamped all-in-one

Key Features:

• Product reviews with photo/video
• Points-based loyalty program
• Automated review requests
• VIP tiers (loyalty)
• Referral rewards (loyalty)
• Questions & Answers
• Instagram integration
• Email automation
• SEO-optimized reviews
• Analytics for both reviews and loyalty

Pricing:

• Free Plan: Limited reviews, no loyalty
• Basic: $23/month (reviews only)
• Premium: $59/month (reviews + loyalty)
• Professional: $149/month (advanced features)

Pros:

• ✅ Two-in-one solution (reviews + loyalty) saves money
• ✅ Strong review features compete with Judge.me
• ✅ Lower pricing than Yuko or Growave for a similar combo
• ✅ Good Instagram integration
• ✅ Active development with regular updates

Cons:

• ❌ Loyalty features are less sophisticated than BON’s dedicated focus
• ❌ No standalone loyalty pricing (must pay for reviews too)
• ❌ Interface can feel dated
• ❌ Some advanced features locked to the Professional tier

Bottom Line:

Stamped.io is a smart alternative if you need reviews + loyalty and prefer paying for one app. BON offers more advanced loyalty features, but Stamped’s review capabilities make it a better overall value if you need both.

Feature-by-Feature: What You Actually Get

Here’s a comprehensive comparison showing true feature availability and costs:

Feature	BON	Yuko	Joy	Smile	Rivo	Growave	LoyaltyLion	Yotpo
Points Program	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
VIP Tiers	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Referrals	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	❌ No	✅ Yes
Reviews	❌ No	✅ Yes	❌ No	❌ No	❌ No	✅ Yes	❌ No	✅ Yes
Memberships	❌ No	✅ Yes	Limited	❌ No	❌ No	❌ No	❌ No	✅ Yes
API Access	Limited	✅ Pro plan	Enterprise	✅ Growth+	✅ Plus plan	Limited	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
POS Integration	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Multi-Language	✅ 250+	✅ 50+	✅ 20+	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Email Automation	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
SMS Automation	❌ No	Limited	❌ No	❌ No	❌ No	❌ No	❌ No	✅ Yes($$$)
Custom CSS	Limited	✅ Yes	Limited	Limited	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
24/7 Support	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	Higher tiers	Higher tiers	✅ Yes	Limited	Higher tiers	Higher tiers
Starting Price	$49/mo	$49/mo	$25/mo	$49/mo	Free	$19/mo	$399/mo	$299/mo

Key Takeaways:

Best All-in-One Value: Yuko offers the most features (reviews + loyalty + referrals + memberships) at $49/month, matching BON’s price but with significantly more functionality.

Best Budget Option: Joy Loyalty at $25/month delivers advanced loyalty features for half BON’s cost.

Best Free Plan: Rivo offers unlimited orders on the free plan vs. BON’s 200-order limit.

Best Enterprise: LoyaltyLion and Yotpo provide advanced features BON can’t match, but at 6-8x the price.

How to Switch from BON Loyalty to a Better Alternative (5 Simple Steps)

Worried about losing your customer data when migrating from BON? Don’t be. Switching is easier than you think, and most alternatives offer free migration support.

Step 1: Export Your Data from BON Loyalty

Log in to your BON Loyalty dashboard and export:

• Customer loyalty points and balances
• VIP tier assignments
• Referral program data
• Transaction history
• Customer email lists

BON provides CSV export functionality in the dashboard. If you need help, their support team can assist.

Step 2: Choose Your Alternative

Based on your needs, select the platform that fits best:

• Need everything (reviews + loyalty + referrals)? -> Yuko or Growave
• Just better loyalty? -> Joy Loyalty or Rivo
• Enterprise features? -> LoyaltyLion or Yotpo
• Budget priority? -> Appstle or Joy

Sign up for a free trial to test before fully committing.

Step 3: Import Your Data

Most BON alternatives offer 1-click migration:

• Upload your BON CSV export file
• Match data fields (usually automatic)
• Preview imported data
• Confirm import

Pro tip: Apps like Yuko offer free white-glove migration where their team handles everything for you.

Step 4: Customize Your Program

Configure your new loyalty program:

• Match your brand colors and fonts
• Set up earning and redemption rules
• Configure email templates
• Create VIP tier structure
• Test in preview mode

Setup typically takes 30-60 minutes with modern platforms.

Step 5: Go Live (Zero Downtime)

When ready to switch:

• Disable BON Loyalty widgets
• Enable your new app’s widgets
• Test on desktop and mobile
• Monitor for 24-48 hours
• Notify customers of any changes

Migration timeline: Most merchants complete the process in 1-2 days, including testing.

Need Help?

Most BON alternatives offer migration support:

• Yuko: Free white-glove migration service
• Joy Loyalty: Migration assistance on paid plans
• Smile.io: Dedicated migration support
• Rivo: Help center guides and support

Our Top Pick: The Best BON Loyalty Alternative for Most Shopify Stores

After comparing features, pricing, ease of use, and merchant feedback across 11 platforms, Yuko emerges as the best BON Loyalty alternative for most Shopify merchants-especially those seeking more than just loyalty features.

Why Yuko Stands Out:

Unbeatable Value for All-in-One Needs

At $49/month, Yuko matches BON’s paid plan pricing but delivers reviews, loyalty, referrals, AND memberships-features that would require 3-4 separate apps otherwise. This consolidated approach saves $200-400/month while eliminating integration headaches.

More Features Than BON at the Same Price

BON focuses on loyalty and referrals. Yuko adds:

• Product reviews with photo/video support (BON doesn’t offer this)
• Membership programs for recurring revenue (BON doesn’t offer this)
• More advanced analytics and segmentation
• Better customization options

All-in-One Simplicity

Instead of managing BON + Judge.me (reviews) + another app for memberships, you get one dashboard, one login, one monthly bill. This means cleaner data, easier management, and no integration conflicts.

Easy Migration Process

Import your BON data in minutes with 1-click migration tools, or take advantage of Yuko’s free white-glove migration service. Your points, VIP tiers, and customer data transfer seamlessly.

Built Exclusively for Shopify

Native Shopify integration ensures fast page loads, seamless POS support, and zero coding requirements. Setup takes under 30 minutes.

Responsive 24/7 Support

Average response time under 2 hours with helpful support that actually understands Shopify stores. No enterprise-level bureaucracy-just real help when you need it.

Who Should Choose Yuko?

Yuko is perfect for:

• Growing DTC brands (100-5,000 orders/month) seeking comprehensive retention
• Merchants wanting to consolidate multiple apps into one platform
• Stores needing reviews + loyalty + referrals without premium pricing
• Budget-conscious businesses are refusing to compromise on features
• Brands valuing simplicity and unified customer data

Ready to Save Money and Get More Features?

Try Yuko free for 14 days with no credit card required. Import your BON data, test all features, and see why thousands of merchants are making the switch.

Alternative Recommendations:

If you only need loyalty (no reviews): Choose Joy Loyalty ($25/month) for advanced features at the lowest price, or Rivo (free plan) if you’re extremely budget-conscious.

If you’re enterprise-level (5,000+ orders/month): Choose LoyaltyLion ($199/month) for sophisticated analytics and dedicated account management.

If you need specialized referrals, choose Shopjar ($7/month) for the best referral-specific features and tracking.

If you prioritize brand recognition: Choose Smile.io ($49/month) for the most established platform with 100,000+ merchants.

Stop Settling for Basic Loyalty in 2025

The Shopify app ecosystem has evolved dramatically. You no longer need to choose between affordability and features, or between specialized apps and all-in-one platforms. Whether you choose Yuko’s comprehensive approach, Joy’s budget-friendly power, or specialized apps like Shopjar, you can build better retention programs while saving money.

BON Loyalty is a solid app, but it’s not your only option – and it might not be your best option.

The best time to explore alternatives? Today. Migration is simple, support is ready, and better retention awaits.

Frequently Asked Questions About BON Loyalty Alternatives